Quote from BucStopsHere on 04/11/10 at 5:22pm:Quote from hibousage on 04/11/10 at 9:52am:And BSH...I don't think it's the board's job to get students ready for college, it's to get them ready for whatever comes next. That everyone in Hoover is going to college attitude gets us in trouble often. Not everyone should or even wants to go to college. We should prepare the students for the direction they want to take with their life. Sure, it's HS, and many of them don't know...but some do...and they should not be overlooked or forgotten, or pushed along the same exact path.
I said
part of the BOE's job is to get kids ready for college. True not every Hoover kid goes to college but most in Hoover do, and our kids should have the same preparation as others from the best schools in the state. Every year we compete w/ the likes of Mt Brook & VH for teachers and we have to be able to attract
and keep the very best. It all starts w/ the BOE, who they hire to administer the schools, and the academic curriculum they approve. A BOE member who never attended college has no clue what it takes to succeed at that level of education, and thus is underprepared to manage toward helping anyone aspiring to advance their education beyond HS.
I assume your sentence
"It all starts w/ the BOE, who they hire to administer the schools, and the academic curriculum they approve.". means "Who the BoE hires to administer the schools, and who they hire to approve the curriculum." and not "The BoE is hired to administer the schools and to approve the academic curriculum."?
I would have to say it's preposterous to assume that someone who did not spend 4+ years in college has
"no clue what it takes to succeed at that level of education...". Going to college is not a spectacular achievement. Actually there are many who graduate from college who don't know how to put complete sentences together. 75% of the NFL players come to mind.
Let's now look at some people out there who don't have a college degree who know a thing or two about business:
Mary Kay Ash
Richard Branson
Michael Dell
Walt Disney (high school drop-out)
Henry Ford (high school drop-out)
Bill Gates
Milton Hershey
Steve Jobs
Ty Warner
Frank Lloyd Wright
Here's a 100 more.
I once attended a banquet with a number of very prominent, famous people. A majority of them were in the athletic field and they were there to honor one of their own. Before the main event began, one of these invited participants, a graduate of one of our state universities (I won't reveal the name, but suffice it to say they have more national championship than their main rival), leaned over to me and asked me to read the menu to him. The man couldn't read! And he had a degree!
Some jobs require a degree. I wouldn't want a doctor working on me who didn't attend med school. I wouldn't want my prescription filled by a person who didn't attend pharmacy school. I wouldn't want to be represented in court by someone who didn't attend law school. But I'll take Steve Jobs to run my company over those who ran GM and Chrysler into the ground any day of the week. And I'd rather have Bill Gates run my IT department over anyone with a college degree, or two or five.
Our Board of Education is there to set policy, not to administer the schools. That's why we hire those with master's degrees as principals. Do I think the entire Central Office staff should have degrees in education? Absolutely. Do I think that the Board members need one also? Not at all. Donna Frazier does not have a degree. She runs a successful business. Arnold Singer does not have a degree. He ran a successful company. Terry Young does not have a degree. He runs a successful business. Barry Thomas has a degree. He is the CFO of a company. They are not out of business and I've dealt with them for four years, so I'll assume his company is successful.
Now let me take you back three years. Some very bad financial decisions were made during that time. Any idea who spearheaded them? I'll give you a clue. They had a college degree.
Finally, let's look at some local school background of these candidates.
Terry Young - Loves Spain Park HS. Two years ago he wanted to give a Mercedes Benz to the student with the highest GPA at SP. He wrote a letter to Billy Broadway explaining his motivation behind the move. Luckily it was shot down by Mr. Sweeney, who felt it would send the wrong message to the public.
Donna Frazier - Loves Spain Park HS. Mrs. Frazier supported Mr. Young's "donation" and considers him one of her "closest friends".
Arnold Singer - Has no relatives in any Hoover school. No bias, no allegiance.
Barry Thomas - Treasurer of the Hoover HS Band Boosters. Of course this might explain hhsoutlaw's support of him, and perhaps yours also, BSH. Boosters tend to stick together. Unfortunately that type of thinking got us in trouble a few years ago.
You know what I really liked about the last two appointments? There was no perceived school affiliation, just a City of Hoover affiliation. In order to get back to a neutral school board, we need to stop with the rah-rah of "my high school is better than yours" and appoint people who care more about all of the kids in our school system than if Hoover beat SP or if SP beat Hoover. Only one candidate can bring that type of thinking to the table. Only one.